Fight Back! News

News and Views from the People's Struggle

Angry Bozeman residents shut down city commission meeting after commissioners vote 5-0 for grants requiring collaboration with ICE

By Julian Staggs

Bozeman, MT – Angry community members attended the Bozeman city commission meeting this November 17 in opposition to the city approving grants which include provisions mandating the city cooperate with ICE.

During the four-hour meeting, over 50 individuals gave in person public comments over the course of three hours, with another 50 supplying written comments, in opposition to accepting these grants, which totaled only $160,000 in value. Despite this, the city commission voted 5-0 to approve the grant, resulting in jeers, chants and shouts from the audience, ultimately shutting down the meeting.

Item H.2 on the agenda was to accept a federal grant for the DHS for around $160,000 to be used for HAZMAT suits and preventative cancer screenings for cancer. Local organizers took issue with subclauses hidden in the grant establishing conditions for acceptance that would mandate Bozeman cooperation with ICE.

Individuals came out in opposition to the item after groups such as the Students for a Democratic Society, Montana 4 Palestine, Bozeman United Against Trump, and the Freedom Road Socialist Organization, spread awareness the preceding week.

Before the meeting, Bozeman Mayor Joey Morrison and Commissioner Emma Bode commented on the agenda item, stating that they disapproved of Bozeman working with ICE but thought that the terms in the grant were “legally unenforceable,” and that the city could win a lawsuit to have the terms thrown out.

Several lawyers gave comments rebutting this claim. Emma Shahabi, a Bozeman-based lawyer who stated she previously worked for the federal government, commented, “This will take a lawsuit, and it will take a lawsuit here in the district of Montana,” adding, “That would take years, it would take hundreds of thousands of dollars in legal fees, and I can name two out of the five federal district judges in Montana I can see ruling against this. I don’t think that’s a sure bet.”

Another individual who identified themselves as a Colombian immigrant and naturalized citizen commented, “I understand the city attorney's view that these conditions are likely unenforceable, but his memo also says he can not give a definite opinion. We simply can not rely on the possibility that these conditions may later prove unenforceable.”

Bozeman resident Natsuki Nakamura questioned the police department’s willingness to not cooperate with ICE, “There is discretion in BPD’s policy to assist ICE.” she said, “When ICE was here this summer, BPD in fact did not tell them to ‘kick rocks.’ I and others personally witnessed BPD acting as security, patrolling around the hotel ICE agents were staying at.”

After public comment, Commissioner Emma Bode began to give her rationale for voting in favor of accepting the grant when a high school student and others interjected, saying, “We might have had our turn [to speak], but it doesn’t seem like you guys listened to any of it.”

Emma Bode singled the student out and threatened to have her removed if she continued, citing the commission’s “three strikes policy,” despite numerous other people also interjecting at the same time.

Ultimately, despite these threats, the crowd’s interjections, boos, jeers and clapping continued throughout the meeting.

After the commission voted 5-0 in favor of accepting the grants, the room exploded as the audience called out the commissioners, with a chant of “This commission needs to listen” emerging as the meeting was shut down and the commissioners, as well as Mayor Joey Morrison, left the room.

The meeting only resumed ten minutes later, after residents left the room in anger at the commission.

A member of Montana 4 Palestine stated, “Tonight the city commission signed up to work with ICE. They stated they have no intention of following the contract they just signed, but the fact is, they signed the contract.”

#BozemanMT #MT #ImmigrantRights #ICE